Marketplace vs. Custom eCommerce Website: Which Is Best for Business in 2023?

As more and more businesses shift towards online sales, many organizations have increasingly questioned whether they should use a marketplace or a custom eCommerce website. In this blog post, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of both options to help you decide which one is best for your business in 2023.

Marketplace:

A marketplace is an online platform where businesses can sell their products alongside other merchants. Some popular marketplaces include Amazon, eBay, and Etsy. Here are some advantages and disadvantages of using an online marketplace:

Pros:

• Exposure: Marketplaces already have a large customer base, so you can take advantage of that exposure to reach a wider audience.
• Trust: Customers tend to trust marketplaces more than individual websites because they know they can rely on the marketplace’s policies and reputation.
• Low Startup Costs: Marketplaces typically charge a commission on sales, so you don’t need to spend a lot of money upfront to start selling.
• SEO Benefit: Marketplace platforms take care of Search Engine Optimization (SEO), helping your products get discovered in search engines.
• High Traffic: Marketplaces attract high traffic, giving you access to a large customer base.
• Less Financial Risks: The financial risk is lower given the pay-as-you-go model of marketplaces, where you pay commission on actual sales.

Cons:

• Limited Control: When you sell on a marketplace, you have limited control over the look and feel of your store, the customer experience, and the pricing structure.
• Competition: Because multiple merchants are selling similar products on a marketplace, there is more competition, which can often make it harder to stand out.
• Fees: Marketplaces charge fees on every sale, which can add up quickly and cut your profits.
• Lack of Branding and Personalization: While selling on a marketplace, you cannot showcase your brand’s unique identity and tailor the shopping experience for your customers.

Custom eCommerce Website:

A custom eCommerce website is a site that you create and manage yourself. Here are some advantages and disadvantages of using a custom eCommerce website:

Pros:

• Control: With a custom eCommerce website, you have entire control over the look and feel of your store, the customer experience, and the pricing structure.
• Branding: You can create a unique brand identity for your website, which can help you stand out from the competition.
• Ownership: You own your website, which means you’re not subject to the policies and rules of a third-party marketplace.
• Accessibility to Customer Insights: Having your website means you have direct access to your customer data. These insights can be used to refine your marketing and sales strategies.
• Design Marketing Campaigns: You can design and implement your marketing campaigns tailored to your target audience.
• Personalization: A custom website allows you to personalize the shopping experience for your customers, something not possible in a marketplace.

Cons:

• High Startup Costs: Creating a custom eCommerce website requires a considerable investment of time and money, especially if you hire a developer to build it for you.
• Marketing: Because you’re starting from scratch, you’ll need to invest time and money in marketing campaigns to bring customers to your website.
• Trust: Because your website is unknown, customers may be hesitant to trust you and may be more likely to buy from a well-known marketplace instead.

The key differences between a marketplace and a custom eCommerce website are:

• Ownership: With a custom eCommerce website, you own your website and have complete control over it. When you sell on a marketplace, however, you are subject to the rules and policies of the marketplace.
• Control: With a custom eCommerce website, you have complete control over the look and feel of your store, the customer experience, and the pricing structure. With a marketplace, you have limited control over these aspects.
• Exposure: Marketplaces already have a large customer base, so you can take advantage of that exposure to reach a wider audience. With a custom eCommerce website, you must invest in marketing to bring customers to your site.
• Fees: Marketplaces charge fees on every sale, which can easily eat into your profits. With a custom eCommerce website, you only pay for hosting and payment processing fees.
• Branding: With a custom eCommerce website, you can create a unique brand identity for your website, which can make you stand out from the competition. With a marketplace, you are one of many merchants selling similar products.
• Trust: Customers tend to trust marketplaces more than individual websites because they know they can rely on the marketplace’s policies and reputation. With a custom eCommerce website, you need to build trust with your customers.

Conclusion:

Both marketplaces and custom eCommerce websites have pros and cons, so there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Ultimately, the best option for your business will depend on your unique goals, budget, and resources. If you’re just starting out and want to minimize costs, a marketplace may be the way to go. If you’re looking to create a unique brand identity and have more control over your store, a custom eCommerce website may be the better choice. Whatever you decide, make sure you do your research and choose the option that aligns best with your business goals.

What Next?

• Analytix Solutions offers top eCommerce development services. If you want to create your eCommerce store, contact us today.
• Email us at sales@analytix.com or call us at 781.503.9003 today.
• Follow our blog for industry trends and the latest updates.
• Engage with us on LinkedIn and Twitter.